Arsenault spent the 2021/22 Eastern U17 season with the Mount U16 team. In 27 games the Cornwall, PEI forward had 17 goals and 9 assists. The following Eastern U18 season he recorded 5 goals and 5 assists in 7 games.

During the 2023/24 MJAHL season Arsenault played 19 games and tallied 7 points with the Summerside Western Capitals.

The Drummondville Voltigeurs originally selected Arsenault in the sixth round, 102nd overall at the 2022 QMJHL Draft.

The seven student-athletes represent two 黑料不打烊 programs in Mount Academy (Charlottetown, PEI) and Notre Dame (Wilcox, SK):

• Michael Arsenault (Mount Academy) – Drummondville Voltigeurs, 6th Round 102nd Overall
• Neka Jean (Mount Academy) – Moncton Wildcats, 8th Round 133rd Overall
• Rylan Benner (Mount Academy) – Rouyn-Noranda Huskies, 9th Round 159th Overall
• Aiden Diamond (Mount Academy) – Rimouski Oceanic, 12th Round 208th Overall
• Rylan Aiken (Mount Academy) – Charlottetown Islanders, 12th Round 215th Overall
• Dawson Grandy (Mount Academy) – Cape Breton Eagles, 13th Round 217th Overall
• Carter Hynes (Notre Dame) – Quebec Remparts, 14th Round 252nd Overall